A United Nations review of the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty is ending in failure today, according to
a Japanese delegate who said there is no agreement on new steps
toward disarmament or measures to block nuclear programs in Iran
and North Korea.
``We lost an opportunity to send out important messages on
issues such as North Korea, Iran and the Comprehensive Nuclear
Test Ban Treaty,'' Japanese envoy Mine Yoshiki told reporters at
the UN. ``Some countries put the emphasis on nonproliferation,
some on disarmament, and we could not get any agreement.''
None of the three committees created to deal with the issues
of disarmament, proliferation, peaceful uses of nuclear energy
and terms of withdrawal from the treaty presented a substantive
report. Brazilian diplomat Sergio Duarte, president of the
conference, began the last meeting by telling delegates there
would be no comprehensive outcome document.
The conference, a five-year review of the 1970 treaty, began
on May 2 with Secretary-General Kofi Annan telling delegates that
``the consequences of failure are too great to aim for anything
less'' than new measures to block proliferation of nuclear
weapons and reduce the number of existing arms.
Iran, North Korea
The U.S. called for amendments to the treaty to block the
development of nuclear weapons by Iran and North Korea, or a
determination to refer those issues to the UN Security Council.
Delegations led by Egypt and Iran demanded assurances of the
nuclear powers that they wouldn't attack non-nuclear nations, and
that they would ratify the proposed test ban treaty.
Neither side compromised and the delegates didn't adopt an
agenda until May 11 or refer key issues to committees until May
19, leaving too little time for agreements.
``This appears to be the most acute failure in the treaty's
history,'' Thomas Graham, a U.S. envoy to disarmament talks under
Democratic U.S. President Bill Clinton told reporters at the UN
yesterday. ``It comes at a time when the treaty is under heavy
pressure, weaker than it has ever been because of the Iranian and
North Korean situations, and will have an effect on keeping the
regime going.''
Diplomats put much of the blame on the U.S., saying the
Republican Bush administration wasn't willing to reaffirm
disarmament commitments made at previous conferences or allow
discussion of a nuclear-free zone in the Middle East that would
include destruction of Israel's undeclared arms. Israel, which
has never acknowledged having nuclear weapons, has not ratified
the treaty.
Blaming the U.S.
``You need to compromise, show recognition for the key
priorities of other states,'' Paul Meyer, head of Canada's
delegation, said in an interview. ``The positions of the vast
majority of states have to be acknowledged, but we did not get
that kind of diplomacy from the U.S.''
Former U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara, a
Democrat, said in a news conference at the UN yesterday that U.S.
nuclear policies were ``immoral, illegal, militarily unnecessary
and destructive of the non-proliferation regime that has served
us so well over the 40 years.''
Richard Grenell, spokesman for the U.S. mission to the UN,
said Egypt and Iran sabotaged the conference by blocking
agreement on an agenda until May 11. He said the U.S. wanted to
use the ``precious'' remaining time to deal with the emerging
problems of Iran and North Korea rather than discussing past
disarmament commitments.
U.S. Nuclear Deterrent
``This conference is as much about nonproliferation as it is
disarmament,'' Grenell said. ``We have discussed disarmament,
made commitments and are proud of our record. But a credible U.S.
nuclear deterrent is an important statement that will always be
there.''
North Korea, which has said it has nuclear weapons, withdrew
from the treaty in 2003 and didn't attend the conference. U.S.
officials met North Korean representatives at the UN on May 13,
the first such meeting in six months, amid efforts to convince
the communist country to restart talks aimed at dismantling its
nuclear weapons that include the U.S., Japan, China, South Korea
and Russia.
Iran agreed last November to suspend its enrichment of
uranium, a program the U.S. believes is meant to produce nuclear
weapons, during talks with the U.K., Germany and France. Iran
said after a May 25 meeting with European nations, known as the
EU-3, that it would continue the suspension while they prepare a
``detailed proposal'' to end the crisis.
``At the same time the conference was arguing about
procedures the EU countries were negotiating a continuation of
Iran's enrichment moratorium, which shows that the most important
nonproliferation work is being done in capitals and not at the
UN,'' former U.S. State Department policy planner and Pentagon
adviser Lee Feinstein, a fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, said in an interview.