An authoritative study of the biological
relationships vital to maintaining life has found disturbing
evidence of man-made degradation. Steve Connor reports
Planet Earth stands on the cusp of disaster and people
should no longer take it for granted that their children and
grandchildren will survive in the environmentally degraded
world of the 21st century. This is not the doom-laden talk of
green activists but the considered opinion of 1,300 leading
scientists from 95 countries who will today publish a detailed
assessment of the state of the world at the start of the new
millennium.
The report does not make jolly reading. The academics found
that two-thirds of the delicately-balanced ecosystems they
studied have suffered badly at the
hands of man over the past
50 years.
The dryland regions of the world, which account for 41 per
cent of the earth's land surface, have been particularly badly
damaged and yet this is where the human population has grown
most rapidly during the 1990s.
Slow degradation is one thing but sudden and irreversible
decline is another. The report identifies half a dozen
potential "tipping points" that could abruptly change things
for the worse, with little hope of recovery on a human
timescale.
Even if slow and inexorable degradation does not lead to
total environmental collapse, the poorest people of the world
are still going to suffer the most, according to the
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, which drew on 22 national
science academies from around the world.
Walt Reid, the leader of the report's core authors, warned
that unless the international community took decisive action
the future looked bleak for the next generation. "The bottom
line of this assessment is that we are spending earth's
natural capital, putting such strain on the natural functions
of earth that the ability of the planet's ecosystems to
sustain future generations can no longer be taken for
granted," Dr Reid said.
"At the same time, the assessment shows that the future
really is in our hands. We can reverse the degradation of many
ecosystem services over the next 50 years, but the changes in
policy and practice required are substantial and not currently
under way," he said.
The assessment was carried out over the past three years
and has been likened to the prestigious Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change - set up to investigate global warming
- for its expertise in the many specialisms that make up the
broad church of environmental science.
In summary, the scientists concluded that the planet had
been substantially "re-engineered" in the latter half of the
20th century because of the pressure placed on the earth's
natural resources by the growing demands of a larger human
population.
"Over the past 50 years, humans have changed ecosystems
more rapidly and extensively than at any time in human
history, largely to meet rapidly growing demands for food,
fresh water, timber and fibre," the reports says.
The full costs of this are only now becoming apparent. Some
15 of the 24 ecosystems vital for life on earth have been
seriously degraded or used unsustainably - an ecosystem being
defined as a dynamic complex of plants, animals and
micro-organisms that form a functional unit with the
non-living environment in which the coexist.
The scale of the changes seen in the past few decades has
been unprecedented. Nearly one-third of the land surface is
now cultivated, with more land being converted into cropland
since 1945 than in the whole of the 18th and 19th centuries
combined.
The amount of water withdrawn from rivers and lakes for
industry and agriculture has doubled since 1960 and there is
now between three and six times as much water held in man-made
reservoirs as there is flowing naturally in rivers.
Meanwhile, the amount of nitrogen and phosphorus that has
been released into the environment as a result of using farm
fertilisers has doubled in the same period . More than half of
all the synthetic nitrogen fertiliser ever used on the planet
has been used since 1985.
This sudden and unprecedented release of free nitrogen and
phosphorus - important mineral nutrients for plant growth -
has triggered massive blooms of algae in the freshwater and
marine environments. This is identified as a potential
"tipping point" that can suddenly destroy entire ecosystems.
"The Millennium Assessment finds that excessive nutrient
loading is one of the major problems today and will grow
significantly worse in the coming decades unless action is
taken," Dr Reid said.
"Surprisingly, though, despite a major body of monitoring
information and scientific research supporting this finding,
the issue of nutrient loading barely appears in policy
discussions at global levels and only a few countries place
major emphasis on the problem.
"This issue is perhaps the area where we find the biggest
'disconnect' between a major problem related to ecosystem
services and the lack of policy action in response," he
said.
Abrupt changes are one of the most difficult things to
predict yet their impact can be devastating. But is
environmental collapse inevitable?
"Clearly, the dual trends of continuing degradation of most
ecosystem services and continuing growth in demand for these
same services cannot continue," Dr Reid said.
"But the assessment shows that over the next 50 years, the
risk is not of some global environmental collapse, but rather
a risk of many local and regional collapses in particular
ecosystem services. We already see those collapses occurring -
fisheries stocks collapsing, dead zones in the sea, land
degradation undermining crop production, species extinctions,"
he said.
Between 1960 and 2000, the world population doubled from
three billion to six billion. At the same time, the global
economy increased more than six-fold and the production of
food and the supply of drinking water more than doubled, with
the consumption of timber products increasing by more than
half.
Meanwhile, human activity has directly affected the
diversity of wild animals and plants. There have been about
100 documented extinctions over the past century but
scientists believe that the rate at which animals and plants
are dying off is about 1,000 times higher than natural,
background levels.
"Humans are fundamentally and to a significant extent
irreversibly changing the diversity of life on earth and most
of these changes represent a loss of biodiversity," the
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment says.
The distribution of species across the world is becoming
more homogenous as some unique animals and plants die out and
other, alien species are introduced into areas in which they
would not normally live, often with devastating impact.
For example, the Baltic Sea contains 100 non-native
species, of which about one-third come from the Great Lakes of
North America. Meanwhile, a similar proportion of the 170
non-native species found in the Great Lakes come from the
Baltic.
"In other words, the species in any one region of the world
are becoming more similar to other regions.... Some 10 to 30
per cent of mammals, birds and amphibians are currently
threatened with extinction. Genetic diversity has declined
globally, particularly among cultivated species," the report
says.
Agricultural intensification, which brought about the green
revolution that helped to feed the world in the latter part of
the 20th century, has increased the tendency towards the loss
of genetic diversity. "Currently 80 per cent of wheat area in
developing countries and three-quarters of all rice planted in
Asia is now planted to modern varieties," the report says. Dr
Reid said that the authors of the assessment were most worried
about the state of the earth's drylands - an area covering 41
per cent of the land surface and home to a total of two
billion people, many of them the poorest in the world.
Drylands are areas where crop production or pasture for
livestock is severely limited by rainfall. Some 90 per cent of
the world's dryland regions occur in developing countries
where the availability of fresh water is a growing
problem.
One-third of the world's people live in dryland regions
that have access to only 8 per cent of the world's renewable
supply of water, the scientists found. "We were particularly
alarmed by the evidence of strong linkages between the
degradation of ecosystem services in drylands and poverty in
those regions," Dr Reid said.
"Moreover, while historically, population growth has been
highest in either urban areas or the most productive
ecosystems such as cultivated lands, this pattern changed in
the 1990s and the highest percentage rate of growth is now in
drylands - ecosystems with the lowest potential to support
that growth.
"These problems of ecosystem degradation and the harm it
causes for human well-being clearly help set the stage for the
conflict that we see in many dryland regions including parts
of Africa and central Asia," he said.
Poor people living in dryland regions are at the greatest
risk of environmental collapse. Many of them already live
unsustainably - between 10 and 20 per cent of the soil in the
drylands are eroded or degraded.
"Development prospects in dryland regions of developing
countries are especially dependent on actions to slow and
reverse the degradation of ecosystems," the Millennium
Assessment says.
So what can be done in a century when the human population
is expected to increase by a further 50 per cent?
The board of directors of the Millennium Assessment said in
a statement: "The overriding conclusion of this assessment is
that it lies within the power of human societies to ease the
strains we are putting on the nature services of the planet,
while continuing to use them to bring better living standards
to all.
"Achieving this, however, will require radical changes in
the way nature is treated at every level of decision-making
and new ways of co-operation between government, business and
civil society. The warning signs are there for all of us to
see. The future now lies in our hands," it said.
Asked what we should do now and what we should plan to do
over the next 50 years, Dr Reid replied that there must be a
fundamental reappraisal of how we view the world's natural
resources. "The heart of the problem is this: protection of
nature's services is unlikely to be a priority so long as they
are perceived to be free and limitless by those using them,"
Dr Reid said.
"We simply must establish policies that require natural
costs to be taken into account for all economic decisions," he
added.
"There is a tremendous amount that can be done in the short
term to reduce degradation - for example, the causes of some
of the most significant problems such as fisheries collapse,
climate change, and excessive nutrient loading are clear -
many countries have policies in place that encourage excessive
harvest, use of fossil fuels, or excessive fertilisation of
crops.
"But as important as these short-term fixes are, over the
long term humans must both enhance the production of many
services and decrease our consumption of others. That will
require significant investments in new technologies and
significant changes in behaviour," he explained.
Many environmentalists would agree, and they would like
politicians to go much further.
"The Millennium Assessment cuts to the heart of one of the
greatest challenges facing humanity," Roger Higman, of Friends
of the Earth, said.
"That is, we cannot maintain high standards of living, let
alone relieve poverty, if we don't look after the earth's
life-support systems," Mr Higman said.
"Yet the assessment hasn't gone far enough in specifying
the radical solutions needed. At the end of the day, if we are
to respect the limits imposed by nature, and ensure the
well-being of all humanity, we must manage the global economy
to produce a fairer distribution of the earth's resources," he
added.
THE TIPPING POINTS TO CATASTROPHE
NEW DISEASES
As population densities increase and living space extends
into once pristine forests, the chances of an epidemic of a
new infectious agent grows. Global travel accentuates the
threat, and the emergence of Sars and bird flu are prime
examples of diseases moving from animals to humans.
ALIEN SPECIES
The introduction of an invasive species - whether animal,
plant or microbe - can lead to a rapid change in ecosystems.
Zebra mussels introduced into North America led to the
extinction of native clams and the comb jellyfish caused havoc
to 26 major fisheries species in the Black Sea.
ALGAL BLOOMS
A build up of man-made nutrients in the environment has
already led to the threshold being reached when algae blooms.
This can deprive fish and other wildlife of oxygen as well as
producing toxic substances that are a danger to drinking
water.
CORAL REEF COLLAPSE
Reefs that were dominated by corals have suddenly changed
to being dominated by algae, which have taken advantage of the
increases in nutrient levels running off from terrestrial
sources. Many of Jamaica's coral reefs have now become algal
dominated.
FISHING STOCKS
Overfishing can, and has, led to a collapse in stocks. A
threshold is reached when there are too few adults to maintain
a viable population. This occurred off the east coast of
Newfoundland in 1992 when its stock of Atlantic cod
vanished.
CLIMATE CHANGE
In a warmer world, local vegetation or land cover can
change, causing warming to become worse. The Sahel region of North Africa depends on rainfall for its vegetation. Small changes in rain can result in loss of vegetation, soil erosion and further decreases in rainfall.